Hawkins v. Town of Shaw
In Hawkins v. Town of Shaw (1971), the US Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the unequal distribution of public services by local governments violated the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The class-action lawsuit, filed by Andrew Hawkins, an African American resident of the town of Shaw in Bolivar County, challenged the pervasive practice of providing fewer and inferior public services and infrastructure in minority neighborhoods than in white neighborhoods.
The landmark decision established the legal principle of equality in public services and expanded the scope of judicial action against civil rights violations by local governments. The ruling also lowered the burden of proof in cases alleging equal protection violations, establishing that plaintiffs did not need to prove racially discriminatory intent, only racially disproportionate impact. The US Supreme Court subsequently re-established proof of discriminatory intent as a legal requirement in equal protection claims in Washington v. Davis (1976), limiting the applicability of the Shaw decision.
During the first half of the twentieth century, cities and towns across Mississippi invested in improvements to civic infrastructure: laying water mains, establishing wastewater treatment systems, covering stormwater sewers, paving streets, and equipping residential areas with sidewalks and streetlights. Invariably, municipalities provided these tax-funded services on a discriminatory basis, with Black residential areas often lacking these services and amenities entirely or being provided a distinctly inferior quality. By the 1960s, inequality in municipal services had emerged as a chief issue for local Black freedom movements across the South—one that tied so many of the injustices, indignities, and threats to health and safety that Black people experienced together.
For civil rights attorneys, equalizing municipal services constituted the logical extension of the previously successful fights to desegregate schools and public accommodations. In 1965, the Jackson office of the NAACP Legal Defense and Education Fund resolved to challenge the constitutionality of municipalities’ unequal provision of public services on equal protection grounds. That same year, Andrew Hawkins, a carpenter who had been active in local civil rights and labor organizing, his wife Mary Lou, and twenty other Black residents filed a complaint against the town of Shaw over its failure to provide the same services for Black residential areas as it provided for whites, despite funding these services through general tax revenues collected from white and Black residents alike.
At the time, the Shaw’s white and Black populations were neatly divided by Porter’s Bayou, which ran through the center of town, with 97 percent of its Black residents residing north of the bayou. Typical of other southern towns, Shaw neglected to pave or grade most of the roads on the Black side of town. In place of underground sewers, open trenches carried stormwater and human waste past Black families’ homes. To cut costs, the town laid smaller, one- to two-inch water mains on the Black side of town (compared to the eight-inch mains in white areas), resulting in severely low water pressure. This, coupled with the relative dearth of fire hydrants in Black neighborhoods, meant that fires that broke out in Black homes were rarely contained and resulted in multiple fatalities.
After meeting with attorneys for the LDF, Hawkins agreed to be the lead plaintiff in a class-action lawsuit against the town of Shaw, filed in the US District Court for the Northern District of Mississippi in 1968. White town officials and employers subsequently embarked on a campaign of intimidation and harassment against the Black residents who had signed the complaint. Within months of the court filing, the Hawkins family home burned to the ground in a suspected case of arson. Local law enforcement refused to investigate.
Despite a preponderance of evidence of racial disparity in municipal services, US District Court Judge William C. Keady dismissed the complaint with prejudice, citing a lack of evidence of racially discriminatory intent. In its appeal to the Fifth District, LDF attorneys Jonathan Shapiro and Reuben Anderson argued that the statistical evidence revealing a clear pattern of discrimination based on race alone warranted strict scrutiny of the town’s practices for possible equal protection violations. The appeals court agreed, reversing the lower court decision. Writing for the majority, Judge Elbert Tuttle concluded, “While there may be many reasons why [poor and dilapidated] areas exist in nearly all our cities, one reason that cannot be accepted is the discriminatory provision of municipal services based on race.” Regardless of whether it could be proved that town officials intentionally discriminated against Black residents because of race, the fact that Black residents lacked these services alone required a legal remedy. Shaw officials appealed the ruling, which was subsequently considered and upheld by the full Circuit Court. Citing lack of resources, the town opted not to appeal to the US Supreme Court.
Civil rights attorneys and activists hailed the ruling as historic, with some commentators likening it to the Brown v. Board of Education decision. In the wake of the decision, the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law formed the Government Services Equalization Center and filed lawsuits against six other towns in Mississippi as well as towns in Michigan and Louisiana. But the legal principle established in the case was severely undermined by the US Supreme Court decision in Washington v. Davis (1976), in which the court ruled that evidence of racially disproportionate effects must also be accompanied by proof of discriminatory intent to constitute an equal protection violation, expressly singling out the lower court’s ruling in Hawkins v. Town of Shaw as one that failed to meet this new standard.
In the aftermath of the court’s decision, the Hawkins family suffered severe retaliation. In 1972, Mary Lou Hawkins was shot and killed by a police officer following a dispute over local law enforcement’s incessant harassment of the family. The family’s home was subject to repeated arson attacks. A fire set in the home in 1979 killed Andrew and Mary Lou Hawkins’s son, Andrew Jr., and two of their grandchildren, Bernadette (age eleven) and Mary Yvette (age eight).
Further Reading
- Charles M. Haar and Daniel W. Fessler, The Wrong Side of the Tracks: A Revolutionary Rediscovery of the Common Law Tradition of Fairness in the Struggle Against Inequality (1986)
- Andrew W. Kahrl, The Black Tax: 150 Years of Theft, Exploitation, and Dispossession in America (2024)



